Red Dead Redemption 2: Kill Or Spare – The Moral Dilemma Of Arthur Morgan

Is it better to spare or kill O Driscoll?

This choice is made difficult simply by being the first time the player has to make a decision presented by the game, which is always unnerving. Ultimately the decision does not matter. You can either choke the O’Driscoll to death or leave him to freeze in the cold, whatever is best for Arthur’s character.

Is it better to be good or evil in Red Dead Redemption 2?

High honor leads to reduced prices, better loot, and more outfits, while low honor yields more loot and discounts on deadeye tonics. Being good in the game requires sacrifices, while being bad has fewer rewards, but low honor makes gameplay easier and less stressful.

Should you kill or spare Jean-Marc?

At a glance, making the decision to kill a character in a side mission may not seem like a big deal, but it definitely helps from a storytelling standpoint for the player. Sparing Jean-Marc is the morally right thing to do, leading to the Mayor’s corruption being revealed and Arthur gaining Honor.

What happens if you spare Anthony RDR2?

If Foreman is spared by Arthur in 1899, Foreman continues to be a criminal into 1907. The Saint Denis Police Department will have a bounty available for John Marston to capture Foreman alive for $85 dollars.

Is there a good ending in RDR2?

All in all, Red Dead Redemption 2 is a rollercoaster of emotions, most of which are distressing rather than soothing. But all that can be changed with the ‘1899 Happy Ending‘ is exactly what you think it is: a way to get some wholesome closure after all the pain RDR2 put you through.

What happens if you spare Javier?

If Javier is captured instead of killed, he angrily threatens John and curses his family while being locked in a cell.

Is Arthur Morgan evil?

While having low honor, Arthur can be portrayed as an aggressive, cold, callous, selfish, and even sadistic person who has absolutely no qualm about doing some of the worst things that he is capable of: killing innocent townspeople, abusing animals and verbally abusing his fellow gang-members to name a few.

Is 100% worth it in RDR2?

Finishing RDR2’s story isn’t even scratching the surface of what’s needed to clinch Best in the West. It might take the same amount of time to complete the story as it does to hunt for all the required items, so the achievement isn’t worth it for anyone who doesn’t want to double their RDR2 playtime.

What happens if Arthur has low honor?

Arthur’s death is ultimately determined by his honor: with high honor, Arthur succumbs to his tuberculosis and battle wounds, but with low honor, Arthur is killed directly by Micah Bell.

What happens if you don’t kill Jean?

In Idealism and Pragmatism you end up being able to either kill Jean-Marc or spare him. Killing him will get you the 10% discount in all St. Denis shops. Sparing him will get you a special journal entry, and a letter.

How much money do you get if you kill Jean-Marc?

If Jean-Marc is killed: A thank you letter will be received in a few days from Lemieux, and the player will get 10% off in all shops in Saint Denis. However, this will result in a minor Honor loss. If Jean-Marc is spared: He will promise to never mention anything to the newspapers and run off into the distance.

Can you choose ending in RDR2?

Red Dead Redemption II has multiple endings based on player choices, culminating in Arthur Morgan’s death before the epilogue as John Marston. A secret bonus ending is available with 100% completion, showcasing John visiting Arthur’s grave in a touching conclusion to the Western saga.

What is the saddest ending in RDR2?

The end events of Rockstar’s Red Dead Redemption sequel sees our second protagonist Arthur Morgan meet his untimely end. After contracting tuberculosis, Arthur peacefully succumbs to his illness under the sunrise (or he is killed by Micah if you managed to finish the game with low honour).

What is the true RDR2 ending?

Dutch responds by shooting Micah, giving John the chance to pump him full of lead. Dutch then silently leaves. John and Sadie leave with the Blackwater money, returning to John’s ranch, where Abigail, Jack, and Uncle are waiting. This marks the final end of the story of Red Dead Redemption 2.

Does Dutch betray Arthur in RDR2?

He returns to Dutch to inform him of this, but Dutch turns on Arthur and the newly returned John. As Pinkertons invade the camp, Arthur and John flee. Arthur begs John to return to his family. The vengeful Micah soon ambushes him, and Dutch intervenes.

Can Arthur be cured of tuberculosis?

The doctor who visits Arthur explicitly mentions that the disease is not curable. Tuberculosis makes Arthur slower, less likely to heal himself with food and drink. A special item in the game, the ‘Owl Feather Trinket’, powers-up Arthur and partially alleviates the symptoms, but it does not cure tuberculosis.

Does John cry after killing Javier?

Even worse is that should you decide to kill Javier, John will pick up his corpse after shooting him down and carry him to his cell for a moment, weeping Manly Tears of sorrow that he has to bring the corpse to Ross and carry it away by a car as proof in order to claim the bounty.

How to save Javier in 15 seconds?

Make a b-line to Tommy to save Javier within 15 seconds by getting him off of him, then defeat Tommy in 1.5 minutes to meet the gold medal requirements. Remember: Square/X to dodge. Circle/B to attack.

Why didn’t Javier point his gun at Arthur?

It is heavily implied in RDR2 that Javier actually wanted to side with Arthur and John, as he is with Bill, Dutch, Micah and the others turning against on the Arthur and John, with them aiming their guns at them, but Javier is holding his gun upwards and isn’t aiming it at them, showing that he never would shoot his …

Who is the true villain of RDR2?

Micah Bell III is one of the two main antagonists (alongside Andrew Milton) of the 2018 western action-adventure video game Red Dead Redemption 2. He was a spree killer, child murderer, and suspected rapist who was affiliated with the Van der Linde gang, being a hitman who operated for them alongside robberies.

Is John Marston a bad guy?

Although many of his victims deserve to die, John is okay with killing anyone who gets in his way. Sometimes, he even targets innocent people and shows no consideration for their deaths. He frequently threatens Irish into sobering up to be of some use to him.

Who is Arthur Morgan in love with?

Arthur rarely talks about Eliza and Isaac, suggesting that their deaths are still a sore spot for him. Arthur also falls in love with Mary Linton, and they eventually get engaged.

Will there be RDR3?

Summary. Red Dead Redemption 3 is likely in development due to the success of the franchise and the long development time of RDR2. Speculation suggests that RDR3 would be a prequel to maintain the game’s Wild West atmosphere and themes.

Is the $50 book in RDR2 worth it?

Both his pitch and the title of the book he’s selling, Get Rich Quick, make it tempting to buy, even if it does cost $50. The problem with it, like most get rich quick schemes, is that it’s nonsense. There’s nothing in the book about how to make money, and you’ll only find yourself out $50.

Do you get rich in RDR2?

Complete Missions Completing main missions in the game is one of the easiest ways to make money. Without spoiling too much, quests focus on the gang’s attempts to rustle up some extra income. So it comes as no surprise then that they have some of the game’s greatest rewards.

What happens if you don’t help Sadie kill the O Driscolls?

If the player declines, Arthur reiterates that the O’Driscolls are not worth caring about and that he will not help her. He tries to convince Sadie that she is better than this, but Sadie pointedly tells him “that ain’t true” and rides away by herself.

Should I kill the serial killer in RDR2?

In the subsequent scene, you have a choice – kill the serial killer, or let the Sheriff kill him. Do the dirty work yourself and you’ll be rewarded with $20. Keep your gun in its holster and you’ll get nothing but the satisfaction of a job well done.

Will there be RDR3?

Summary. Red Dead Redemption 3 is likely in development due to the success of the franchise and the long development time of RDR2. Speculation suggests that RDR3 would be a prequel to maintain the game’s Wild West atmosphere and themes.

What happens if you kill Herbert Moon RDR2?

If Herbert Moon is killed in a duel, the player will never be informed that a shopkeeper has been killed, whereas if the player kills him outside of a duel, a notification regarding his death will appear and his shop will be unavailable for five days, as with all other shopkeepers.

What happens in Red Dead Redemption 2?

What happens if you break the law in Red Dead Redemption 2?

Is there a Red Dead Redemption 2 subreddit?

What happens if you save the bandit in Red Dead Redemption 2?